9/29 US Nat'ls Prep Tourny: Game 1 Cotter v. Renly3 --- Dance With Dragons
Round 1 Dance with Dragons
Opponent Lists:
My List:
Why I Chose Cotter:
I mentioned my Renly friend in my previous post because we got matched round 1. This kinda sucked because it meant one of us was going to start with a loss. We also practice against each other a ton, so we have a lot of insight into each other's playstyles. Ironically, our last game two nights before the tournament was his Loras list v. my Cotter in DWD. I only played Cotter in that game to test the Marshall and to see how Cotter worked against baratheons. Afterwards, he mentioned next DWD he would play his GCX Renly list as his Loras list lacked mobility to keep up and a range threat to act as a clock …
So obviously I knew he would pick that one lol. I knew the GCX would have to get within 12 of Cotter. With his cards, I felt great about killing that and then playing the movement game to spin the RK around. While Alliser was my planned DWD list, I dislike him playing into the Renly side matchup. Bara wants the grind and I don't see how playing into their strengths leads anywhere good for me.
Ultimately I guessed correctly and the matchup is Cotter v. Renly3
Deployment and Terrain:
Wierwood to center (me), Weirwood right middle (him), stakes right far side (me), bog middle left (him).
My main priority was to place Cotter in center to be able to pivot towards GCX. Unless he charge blocks them (or moves slowly to shield them) -- I will get the matchup I want.
He won roll off and chose to go first. I was happy with this as it gave me final activation in the round and I could deploy my Vanguard to get it. I probably would have picked going second anyway. Verse Bara I don't really see a reason to hold out for a better outflank deployment as I can wrap behind him before he gets to the points. If he pivots around, then I’ll secure the points and start tac repo’ing away.
Round 1:
This is exactly why I like Sam NCU for Cotter. My opening hand was something like Assault Orders, Assault Orders, Light that Brings the Dawn, and Take the Black. A perfect aggro hand for going 2nd. I will have the last tactic board pick and I'll have the swords for round 2. The final round activation was my "go time." If I could get Cotter onto the GCX or Rainbow Guard with my first Assault Orders at end of round, then use my other Assault Orders (or swords if no Courtney token) and kill then I think I'm in the best possible position.
It doesn't show in the photo, but right after I took it I deployed the Vanguard above the bog on his side of the board. I wanted him to feel cramped even though I had 0 intention of going for those Rose Knights. Not engaging with the Rose Knights is seriously always the correct answer.
I get horses and move cotter up. He tac repo's the GCX forward and then marches them to threaten a sword shot. Because I can charge off crown + have fueled by slaughter -- I let this go through, baiting the GCX to get within 12 of Cotter. I even activated Cotter and moved a little forward to show less of a threat. He took the bait and I charge off crowns, healing back all the damage done. I do something like 6 or 7 wounds overall and he uses Bara Conviction to heal two. My trackers take the far left egg and my trusty WM follows Cotter.
Round 2: [NW 1st player]
I with Denys and kill the GCX, surging onto the rightmost point. He attempted to Courtney token swords/bags, but assault orders off horses [to block Rainbow Guard pivot] works just as well. Surging + using a tac repo takes them out of Reny's line of sight. At this point, my Vanguard are just chilling behind his line threatening rear charges and trackers are chilling with the egg trying to use the bog to deter the Rose Knights (who took the center egg). The Vanguard are placed to threaten his Crownland Scouts from trying to go after my Trackers. If he goes for the Trackers, I'll collapse on Renly.
As a note: objectives didn't really have an impact on the game -- despite the center objective having +1 tactics card. Because of Sam, I just let him take letters each time and make use of the other zones -- always trying to end a round where he is first player disengaged so swords is unusable for him.
Honestly nothing much else happened this round, as Renly pivots around to try and fight with Cotter.
Score: 3-1
Round 3: [Bara 1st player]
Nothing is engaged so swords is worthless -- nor does he have anything to heal so bags are worthless.
Time pressure is beginning to mount -- as is the feeling that the game is slipping away. He attempts a YOLO Rainbow Guard charge into Cotter. If I remember right he rolls well, and does considerable damage, but I respond with Swords attack into double Pike's aggression with Denys influence. Resiliance can keep him safe from the first attack, but not the Pike's Aggression that follows. This is a dead Renly and secures the game. I rotate the Vanguard to keep Cotter safe (not necessary given I'm first player next round) and in fact, they should have moved to intercept the Rose Knights. He decides he needs to kill the trackers and gets ready to move towards it.
Score: 6-2
Uneventful - he moves towards Trackers but can't get there this round as I open horse to block it. We talk the round out and reach the final score.
Score: 8-3.
Units Destroyed: 13 v. 0
Summary:
I drew the best cards I possibly could have. 2x Assault Orders before round 2 and both Pike's Aggresssion top of round 3 spelled the end. Part of my issue facing Bara's recently is the 8 point Rose Knights don't seem to accomplish anything. It could be I use a lot of double Cav lists, but the minute they are just spinning around to get engaged, I feel really good. Here I traded the 6 point trackers and 3 VPs for 8 points of Rose Knights and 3 VPs. I'm thrilled with this trade as I think the Rainbow Guard require a little more babysitting.
I really didn't expect to get DWD - although rematches felt like the theme of the day. While this was my aggressive list - I planned to play it defensively. I wanted to burst down the GCX or Rainbow Guard, then use my heavy mobility advantage to spin the Rose Knights around (hopefully down to 2 movement with the Egg). Basically - defense from mobility. If he can't charge me, he can't hurt me. I don't think this game plays out the same way without my draw -- but I feel like the gameplan was strong.








Comments
Post a Comment